Chicory: A Colorful Tale and the Fear of Not Being Good Enough

Hero art: Chicory: A Colorful Tale. Official promotional screenshot supplied through the game’s Steam page. Game by Greg Lobanov and the credited Chicory team; published by Finji. Editorial crop and title treatment by Otherworlds Inc.
Spoiler note: This essay discusses Chicory’s public premise and early design examples, without revealing later character outcomes or the ending.
A rough drawing has an unfortunate advantage over the drawing that exists in your head: everyone can see what is wrong with it. The imagined version keeps its perfect proportions. The actual page has an awkward hand, a face that looked better three lines ago, a patch of color that refuses to belong. Before there is much work to judge, there can already be a strong temptation to stop.
Chicory: A Colorful Tale makes that hesitation an interesting place to begin. In the game’s public premise, a dog takes up a magical brush after the world loses its color. Chicory is the admired artist whose name the game carries. The player begins in the shadow of someone else’s accomplishment, with a tool that makes their own choices visible.
There is a generous proposition in giving someone the brush before they have demonstrated that they deserve it. Participation comes first. Whatever skill follows has somewhere to develop. The more difficult question is how to sustain that generosity inside a game that also contains puzzles, instructions and responses to what the player makes.
What the brush asks of you
Painting in Chicory can do practical work. In an April 2021 interview, before release, creator Greg Lobanov described flowers that shrink when painted, clearing a path. Erasing their color makes them tall enough to stand on. The brush changes how a place can be crossed.
This is a helpful distinction to establish early. A flower’s response gives painting a discoverable rule. The player can understand an effect, try it elsewhere and use it toward a goal. Success in that interaction concerns what the mark does. Nobody needs a beautiful flower to understand a shorter one.
A drawing asks different questions. Where should this line go? What would make the picture funny? Would another color change its mood? Those choices can remain interesting even when they do not open a route. Treating every mark as an answer to a puzzle would narrow the invitation: the brush would become a key with an unusually expressive handle.
In his May 2021 Game Developer interview, Lobanov describes separating creative activities from progression challenges so that expression does not become merely a hurdle. That separation gives the same tool room to serve more than one kind of attention. Sometimes a player needs to work out what the world requires. Sometimes they can decide what they want to leave in it.
For someone worried about being good enough, that difference matters. Being able to solve a problem can build confidence, but it need not become the admission price for having a preference. A favorite color is already a reason to put that color somewhere.

Feedback without a verdict on your worth
The invitation still includes being seen. In the same pre-release Wccftech interview, Lobanov describes art classes that offer a prompt and canvas, then respond procedurally to choices in the drawing. That is feedback within a designed system; it does not establish a meaningful algorithmic judgment of artistic quality.
A response can make an activity feel acknowledged without settling whether the result is accomplished. This is useful territory for a game about creativity. A blank canvas can be intimidating because it provides so little to answer. A prompt offers a starting point, and a response gives the attempt a place in an exchange.
There are limits to the comparison with making art outside a game. A comic page can confuse its readers. A melody can lose its shape. Someone trying to improve may need criticism that identifies a problem accurately, even when hearing it is uncomfortable. Encouragement has little value if it prevents a person from learning what their work actually communicates.
The distinction worth protecting is between assessing a piece and deciding whether its maker was entitled to attempt it. “I cannot follow the action in this panel” offers something to investigate. “I should never have tried drawing” closes the investigation before it starts. Specific feedback leaves room for another version; a judgment about the whole person makes every future page carry the same sentence.
Read this way, Chicory does not need to prove that every picture is equally successful. Its more useful possibility is that an imperfect picture can remain part of a worthwhile activity. Learning to see its weaknesses can coexist with wanting it to exist.
The person behind the accomplishment
Admiration complicates that possibility. Another artist’s finished work can give us a language for what we want to make. It can also become an unfair comparison: their resolved choices beside our visible searching. The influence that opened a door begins to look like evidence that we should stay outside.
Putting an admired artist in the title gives Chicory a productive tension. The name belongs to someone the player looks toward, while the brush asks for the player’s own actions. An example can guide a beginning without determining everything the beginner must eventually become.
Lobanov’s post-release GameMaker interview makes room for a further choice. Alongside creative participation, he discusses burnout and the freedom not to pursue being an artist. That qualification matters to an essay about permission. An invitation to create becomes another demand if accepting it means committing to an artistic identity forever.
There are many possible relationships with making things. Someone might want to learn a craft seriously, share occasional drawings with friends, or spend an afternoon coloring without turning it into a plan. A professional might want a life that asks less of that part of them. These choices have different consequences, but none needs to serve as proof that the earlier pleasure was false.
The fear of not being good enough can survive every milestone if each accomplishment merely raises the next requirement. A more spacious question is what place the activity should have in a life. The answer may include ambition. It may also include limits, privacy or the decision to stop.

The craft that makes room for play
The freedom offered to the player rests on careful work by the developers. Lobanov’s Game Developer interview explains a visual problem: if players can recolor the world, fixed colors cannot do all the work of making it readable. Silhouettes and consistent cues about collision help preserve understanding when the surface changes.
That is a concrete example of skill supporting another person’s freedom. A designer has to anticipate what might become confusing and give the player another way to understand it. The apparent ease of making a mark depends partly on decisions the player may never consciously notice.
The sound has similarly particular origins. In her account of the game’s soundscape, composer Lena Raine describes live woodwinds performed by Kristin Naigus and musical transitions through quieter outskirts. Sound designers Em Halberstadt and Preston Wright worked with recordings of paint and glue for the brush sounds. A digital action acquires texture through people listening to physical materials.
Those details make the discussion of creativity less abstract. There are instruments to perform, substances to record, shapes to clarify. A welcoming work can ask considerable precision of its makers. Respecting that labor does not require turning their accomplishment into a warning to everyone less experienced.
Indeed, the care becomes available to the player as support. Someone has done the difficult work of making a world responsive enough that another person can try something uncertain inside it. That seems a valuable use of expertise: building conditions in which a beginner has room to act.
From our worlds: Before a Lunora page is finished
In a Lunora page shared by Otherworlds Inc., figures gather inside a chamber before a bright burst of energy fills the lower action beat. The rough, inked and colored versions in Guide 5, credited to Kev Liew and Sierra Ashevaili Rottman, let us follow how that moment becomes readable.
The rough places the grouping, faces and movement. Linework resolves figures, statues and architecture. Color brings a cyan center and red accents into the dark chamber, then draws attention toward the burst below. Our reading of the sequence is that each stage answers a different question. The rough can establish where attention needs to travel while leaving much of the finished appearance undecided. Its unfinished state has a purpose.
That makes a useful companion to Chicory: an early version deserves to be understood through the work it is doing. In Lunora, Iko defies fate, bound by love for Lunora, amid vengeful deities and eldritch horrors. Such a premise asks visual storytelling to keep intimate feeling legible within an enormous imagined world. Readers can begin with Issue 1; these working stages offer another way to appreciate the decisions that bring a comic’s world into focus.
A mark can be a beginning
The rough drawing still has its awkward hand. Permission does not fix the proportions, and a kind response cannot make every choice work. What permission changes is the possibility of staying with the page long enough to find out what could happen next.
That is the reading of Chicory worth carrying beyond its brush: the right to participate can come before proof of mastery. Once there is something on the page, there can be observation, feedback and revision. There can also be a small pleasure that never needs to become a career.
A person may keep the drawing, change it or put it away. None of those decisions has to resolve their entire future as an artist. For now, there is a mark that was not there before, and room to decide what it means to make another.
Sources and further reading
- Chicory: A Colorful Tale — official site.
- Greg Lobanov interview, Nathan Birch, Wccftech, April 9, 2021.
- Road to the IGF: Bringing out players’ creativity in Chicory: A Colorful Tale, Joel Couture, Game Developer, May 26, 2021.
- Sharing the Joy of Creation: Chicory’s Greg Lobanov, GameMaker, April 8, 2022.
- The delightful soundscape in Chicory, Lena Raine, PlayStation Blog, June 9, 2021.
- From Rough Layouts to Finished Comic Art, Otherworlds Market; artwork credited to Kev Liew and Sierra Ashevaili Rottman.
Chicory artwork belongs to its credited creators and rights holders. Official promotional screenshots are included for identification and editorial commentary; banner crops and title treatment are by Otherworlds Inc. Character art and animation: Alexis Dean-Jones; environment art: Madeline Berger; direction: Greg Lobanov. Lunora artwork is by Kev Liew and Sierra Ashevaili Rottman, courtesy of Otherworlds Inc. Contact Otherworlds Inc. for credit corrections or rights concerns.




