SIGNALIS: The Horror of Being Replaceable

Elster.
Elster.

SIGNALIS screenshot courtesy of rose-engine. Editorial title treatment by Otherworlds Inc.

This essay discusses the opening of SIGNALIS.

In SIGNALIS, a ship’s manual explains partnership. A pilot flies, a technician assists, and previous crews have done well this way. Imagine being given that page on your first day aboard. It would tell you whose hands you were putting your life in. You could read it again after ten years with the same partner and find that it had acquired nothing to say about either of you.

Elster, the technician at the center of rose-engine’s 2022 survival horror game, is a Replika, an android. There’s a practical argument for writing instructions that can serve whoever signs on next. A manual addressed to one indispensable genius would be a terrible manual. The horror begins with a smaller, more plausible mistake. Someone who knows how to fill a vacancy can easily come to believe they know what was lost when the position fell empty.

Who the instructions are for

Consider how strange it would be for a supervisor to ask two people who have worked closely together what makes them a good pair. One might answer that the other knows when to leave her alone with a difficult problem. The supervisor, anxious to preserve this excellent practice for the next crew, writes down give your partner space. In passing from a person who knows when to step back to a rule that anyone can follow, a piece of good advice has quietly changed its meaning. The difficult part was always knowing when.

Aboard Elster’s ship, a second manual addresses her by model type. It explains the module she can use to repair equipment and her own body. Here the tutorial writer has an unusually intimate way of meeting the player. Anybody who has paused a game to look up a control knows the relief of a clear instruction. For the moment it takes to learn how to tend to an injury, the authority speaking to Elster has something you want from it. You can be grateful for good directions and still wonder who chose the terms.

Elster framed by data and an LSTR readout.
SIGNALIS screenshot courtesy of rose-engine.

In an interview with Thomas Wilde shortly before release, co-creator Yuri Stern described how the pressures of classic survival horror gave the developers room to tell a personal story. It’s a generous way of thinking about what a tutorial can do. A speech about the state would let you stand at a comfortable distance and decide whether you agreed with it. An instruction gives you a reason to pay close attention to every word. For a few seconds, you and its author have a job to do together.

What a stranger can tell you

A wounded guard, STAR, urges Elster to leave. Elster asks after a woman. A photograph fills the screen. Back overhead, STAR knows where the workers went. The face is unfamiliar.

There’s a small courtesy in that answer. Anyone who has asked a stranger for news of someone will recognize the difference between being dismissed and being given the best lead a stranger has. The first kindness any of us might think to extend to an injured stranger is the chance to say what she needs. It takes a moment to consider that she might have a kindness of her own to extend. Knowing where people go in the ordinary course of work is part of a guard’s business. Caring enough to pass that knowledge on is a choice.

Consider what a photograph asks of its viewer. A written description invites a series of small agreements. Right age, right uniform, somebody here may fit. A face offers the other person a chance to say, immediately and with pleasure, that yes, she knows exactly who you mean. That invitation extends to the player. Think of looking through a box of old family snapshots after the aunt who knew everybody has died. The light can be good enough to make out every button on a sleeve. You still put the picture back wondering who you’ve just been looking at.

The next name on the roster

The way to test a good handover is to see whether the work can carry on in somebody’s absence. Friendships have no corresponding test. If you miss the person who used to share your shift, it would be an odd consolation to hear that the new arrival is every bit as capable. You might like the newcomer very much. Given time, you might miss her too.

An administrator finishing the day’s paperwork could have the satisfaction of seeing every last person accounted for. Imagine standing at that desk, picture in hand, with somebody still to find.

Sources and credits

Game by rose-engine. Story by Barbara Wittmann and Yuri Stern. Written and directed by Yuri Stern. Full credits · Official media and release information.

The opening passages can be seen in Ceres Fauna’s recording at 12:00 and 18:00, and in Kotaku’s gameplay at 11:37.

Thomas Wilde interviewed the co-creators for Bloody Disgusting on October 18, 2022. Read the interview.

The childhood passage is from H.S. Crow’s production script for Lunora, Issue 1, Episode 04, script pages 22–23. The accompanying comic page, supplied by H.S. Crow, is labeled Episode 03, page 23 (Childhood Timeline). Series and creative team.

By The Otherworlds Desk

About The Otherworlds Desk

The Otherworlds Desk is the editorial team at Otherworlds Inc., creating articles for Otherworlds Market, the company’s shop. We explore anime, manga, comics, games, mythology, fantasy, science fiction, art, storytelling, and the creative cultures that make imagined worlds feel alive.

Carlos Aramburo is the founder of Otherworlds Inc. and a writer, storyteller, and worldbuilder working across comics, novels, games, music, and transmedia mythology.

Soma is one of the editors and researchers behind The Otherworlds Desk, wandering the crossroads of ancient myth, forgotten histories, and the small enchanted details that make imagined worlds feel alive.

Lilith Ethelwood works in public relations for Otherworlds Inc., helping shape public communication and carry Otherworlds’ stories into the world.